Can A Hernia Heal On Its Own? Three Questions Patients Ask Most.

November 19, 2026 | Hernia

Honest Answers to the Three Questions Patients Ask Most

When someone sits down with Dr. Hesham Atwa after learning they have a hernia, he can usually guess what they are going to ask. In fact, if you look at what people type into Google, it comes down to three primary questions. Can it heal on its own? When is it an emergency? And what does recovery actually look like?

These are good questions, and patients deserve straight answers. Here is how Dr. Hesham Atwa walks his patients through them.

What is a hernia?

A hernia is a bulge that happens when there is a weak spot in the muscle layers of the abdominal wall. Some people are born with that weakness, and others develop it over time. It can happen to men, women, and even children.

The concern with a hernia is not the bulge itself. It is that a piece of the bowel can push through that opening and become trapped. Many people live with a hernia for years without knowing it is there, or without it bothering them at all. Most of Dr. Hesham Atwa’s hernia patients come to him in one of two ways: either they know they have a hernia and it is bothering them, or a CT scan or ultrasound done for some other reason found one by accident.

Can a hernia heal on its own?

This is the number one question, and for adults, the answer is no.

The only time a hernia reliably closes by itself is in young children, usually between the ages of one and four, who have a small umbilical hernia at the belly button. Those often close without surgery. But for anyone older than four, Dr. Hesham Atwa explains, a hernia may slide in and out, and it may be possible to push it back in, but it does not heal and it does not go away. Pushing it back in is not the same as fixing it.

Many patients tell him a story that goes something like this: “I lifted the couch,” or “I was at the gym,” or “I had a terrible cough for two weeks. Did I cause my hernia?” It is a very common worry, but usually the answer is no. More often, the weak spot was already there. Heavy lifting, coughing, straining, or chronic constipation all increase the pressure inside the abdomen, and that pressure looks for the path of least resistance. The small opening in the muscle is exactly that path, so those activities tend to reveal a hernia rather than create one.

Can you just live with it?

For patients who are healthy, Dr. Hesham Atwa recommends having the hernia repaired. That does not mean surgery tomorrow. In most cases it is not urgent, and it is far better to fix a hernia on a calm, scheduled day than in the middle of the night as an emergency.

Researchers have actually studied what happens when hernias are simply watched. In a well-known clinical trial, men with mildly symptomatic groin hernias were followed without surgery. After ten years, roughly two out of three of them had gone on to need an operation anyway, and that number was even higher for men over 65 (Fitzgibbons et al., Annals of Surgery, 2013).

For most people, watching a hernia just postpones a repair that is coming sooner or later, and the longer they wait, the larger the hernia tends to become and the greater the chance it turns into an emergency.

That said, real life matters. Some of Dr. Hesham Atwa’s patients tell him it is their busy season at work and they simply cannot take time off, or that they need to arrange child care first. If the hernia is not causing problems, it is perfectly reasonable to wait a few months and schedule surgery at a better time. There are also situations where watching is the right call. If a scan picks up a tiny hernia that is only a bit of fat, one that neither the patient nor Dr. Hesham Atwa can feel on exam, it can be safely monitored. And for some patients with serious heart or lung disease who may not tolerate anesthesia well, the risks are weighed carefully together. Every person is different, and the plan should fit each patient’s health and life.

A Special Note for Women

Women have a higher chance of developing a type of groin hernia called a femoral hernia. These tend to be smaller, but they are more likely to become stuck. For that reason, Dr. Hesham Atwa generally encourages women with a groin hernia not to wait, and international hernia guidelines make the same recommendation (HerniaSurge Group, 2018).

When is a hernia an emergency?

This is the part Dr. Hesham Atwa most wants patients to remember. A hernia that becomes trapped can cut off its own blood supply, and once that happens, there may be only a matter of hours before the bowel is seriously damaged. This is not something to “sleep on.” Go to the emergency room right away, or call 911, if you notice any of the following:

  • The hernia is swollen, firm, or tender and will not go back in
  • The bulge is painful, especially if the pain is getting worse
  • You are vomiting, or you cannot pass stool or gas
  • The skin over the bulge looks red, purple, or dark

Vomiting and constipation together with a swollen hernia can mean the intestine is blocked. Pain with a bulge that will not go back in can mean the blood supply is in danger. Either way, it needs to be seen.

So, what should you do if it is nine o’clock at night and the bulge has popped out? Dr. Hesham Atwa advises lying down, putting some ice on the area, and gently trying to ease it back in. If it goes back in and is not painful, that is reassuring, and the next step is to call the office to be evaluated. If it will not go back in, or if it hurts, go to the emergency room. Most of the time the hernia can be gently pushed back in there. If not, the next steps may include IV fluids, sometimes a tube to relieve pressure in the stomach, and surgery to repair it safely.

Open, laparoscopic, or robotic: What is the difference?

There are three main ways to repair a hernia, and Dr. Hesham Atwa has performed all of them over the course of his career.

The oldest approach is open surgery, which is how every surgeon trains in residency. It involves a larger incision through the muscle to find the hole and close it. It is still used in some situations, including for patients who cannot have general anesthesia, since it can be done with local anesthesia and sedation.

For the first twenty years of his practice, Dr. Hesham Atwa repaired hernias laparoscopically, using a few small incisions and a camera. Today he uses the surgical robot, and in his hands, it allows a better repair. He can see the area in fine detail, place mesh precisely without using tacks that can cause lingering pain, and repair hernias on both sides during the same operation when needed. For his patients, that has meant a stronger repair, a lower chance of the hernia coming back, and less pain afterward.

What does recovery really look like?

This is where most people are pleasantly surprised. Robotic hernia repair is usually an outpatient procedure. The operation itself takes about 45 minutes to an hour, depending on the size and complexity of the hernia. Patients spend a few hours in recovery, and once the anesthesia wears off, they go home the same day.

For the first day or two, patients feel sore, the way they might after doing a hundred sit-ups. That eases a little more each day, and most people feel like themselves again within seven to ten days.

For the first two weeks, Dr. Hesham Atwa wants patients walking but not lifting anything heavy. After that, they can start with light weights, five or ten pounds, and gradually build back up. The body is a good guide. If something hurts, or there is soreness the next day, that is a sign of pushing a bit too hard, so it is time to ease off. Most of the healing happens over the first six to eight weeks, and after that patients can push themselves more, always stopping if something hurts.

A few comfort measures make a real difference. Most of Dr. Hesham Atwa’s patients do well with Tylenol and Motrin, and he provides a small number of stronger pain pills just in case. He asks all patients to wear an abdominal binder, which supports everything and makes coughing and sneezing much more comfortable, and asks men to wear a jockstrap for the first two weeks. A heating pad over the belly button, where the camera incision is, for about fifteen minutes three times a day, helps relax the muscles and ease soreness.

There is one trap Dr. Hesham Atwa sees often. About a month out, patients feel so good that they forget they had surgery at all. They lift something heavy and feel a twinge or a muscle spasm. It is usually not a big deal, just a reminder from the body to keep building up gradually.

Weight loss, GLP-1 medications, and “new” hernias

More of Dr. Hesham Atwa’s patients are losing significant weight with GLP-1 medications, and some notice a hernia for the first time along the way. In most cases, the hernia was already there. As fat melts away, people start to feel things in their bodies they never noticed before, and a small hernia can suddenly become visible.

Weight loss is actually good news when it comes to hernia repair. When a patient with an umbilical or incisional hernia is carrying extra weight, Dr. Hesham Atwa usually encourages them to lose as much as they safely can before surgery, because it helps recovery and lowers the chance of the hernia coming back. The same goes for other risk factors. Quitting smoking, cutting back on alcohol, and treating a chronic cough or constipation all help protect the repair, so these are addressed before surgery to help the hernia stay fixed.

What are the real risks?

Any surgery carries some risk, and Dr. Hesham Atwa wants his patients to go in with eyes open. With hernia repair, serious complications are uncommon. The main ones to watch for are infection, which is why antibiotics are given at the time of surgery; bleeding, which is why blood thinners are paused beforehand when it is safe to do so; and recurrence, meaning the hernia comes back and may need another repair. There are other possible complications, but they are rare, and each person’s risk depends on their overall health. Dr. Hesham Atwa reviews each patient’s individual risks in detail before surgery.

What surprises people most is how quickly they get back to their lives. Many patients come in nervous and later tell Dr. Hesham Atwa they wish they had not waited so long.

You Need to Know

A hernia will not heal on its own once you are past early childhood, but in most cases, it is not an emergency either. There is time to plan. What Dr. Hesham Atwa does not want is for anyone to wait until it becomes a crisis. If you have a bulge that worries you, or a scan has shown a hernia, he and his team are glad to talk it through and help you decide on the right timing and the right approach.

You can easily schedule a consultation with Dr. Hesham Atwa and the team at Long Island Laparoscopic Doctors.

References:

  • Fitzgibbons RJ Jr, Ramanan B, Arya S, et al. Long-term results of a randomized controlled trial of a nonoperative strategy (watchful waiting) for men with minimally symptomatic inguinal hernias. Annals of Surgery. 2013;258(3):508-515.
  • HerniaSurge Group. International guidelines for groin hernia management. Hernia. 2018;22(1):1-165. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29330835/

Have questions about your treatment options?

Schedule a consultation with our team.

Book a Consultation
Dr. Hesham Atwa